Shave your beard! Mr. Rahul Gandhi

When the country was debating over the landmark judgment of the Apex Court, which entitles them to register their “democratic dissent” over EVMs; something very weird was orchestrated by the first family of the Congress party. Mr. Ajay Maken kept down his phone and announced that the Hon’ble Vice-President of the party padhar rehe hain...

He rushed in! He said what he was asked to say! And he rushed out!!

This Ordinance, in its process and content, is no good. And it does not require any imprimatur from Mr. Rahul Gandhi, the Silent second-leader-on-command. However, he speaking and using hard words raised many eye brows both inside the government and outside.

“It (the Ordinance) is complete non sense. It should be torn up and thrown away. It is my personal opinion.” He said.

I could recall, Mr. B.R.Ambedkar using similar language in Rajya Sabha on 2^nd September 1953, where he said, 

“…I shall be the first person to burn it (the Constitution) out. I do not want it.”

Ambedkar’s frustration is clearly understandable. He said, he was a ‘hack’ and he did what he was asked to do, much against his will. Moreover, in his opinion, “(the Constitution) does not suit anybody”. But when RaGa chooses these languages I politely ask: Why you? Why now?

This Ordinance was placed before the Cabinet and the Representation of People (Second Amendment) Bill, 2013 was introduced in Rajya Sabha under your nose! Were you not aware of? Why this sudden rise of conscience now? Why this grandstanding after Milind Deora’s criticism and BJP’s President meet? Mr. Gandhi, You have to explain! And you have to explain more… why this new Congress line now? Is this UPA government not led by your party? Or have you decided to kick Lalu Prasad out and go ahead with Nitish? 

Importantly, Mr. Rahul! Your bossy élan! Ridiculous! By the way, was it an off-late image building from ‘jack’? Or was a desperate attempt to assert leadership? Have His Excellency tutored you well? Or have you realized that your Rasheed Masood can’t go through and will get pressed down hard under NOTA button, in any case?

Mr. Gandhi! As Mr. Jaitley said ‘damage control exercise’ won’t help! Everyone can see through. You could have been a little more honest. Belated realization, if any could have been communicated better. Snubbing the Prime Minister, when he can’t fight back and using these languages only shows your political iniquity. If you want to look good, shave your beard instead of lathering Manmohan’s. Contrarian approach and Back biting won’t get you vote. Why call this ordinance ‘Non-Sense’, when most of us personally think you to be the one? I sympathize!

A Split

 A Split, both telegenic and telly-bugging... A departure based on apprehension and assessment… A break up where both the partners play victim and no one takes the blame. Yes! It’s not Jiah Khan. Am talking about Janata Dal(U) and its divorce from BJP!

Here is a split, which not only shrivels the already slim NDA but has weakened the force that is anti-Congress. A split that speaks less on Narendra Modi’s polarization and more on Nitish Kumar’s dichotomy. Is it purely a clash of issues and Ideology; or there are things we do not know of? Not being privy to both the camps, it will be unjust if I endorse Sushil Modi, when he says JD(U) is apprehensive of its support base being dented; and equally it will be unreliable if I comment on the tightness of JD(U)’s embracement to the 3^rd resolution in our preamble, which Sikri, C.J. and Chandrachud J. calls to be the basic. But incredible is our political archives and incredulous is our political developments.

As a mugwump when I see it, I find it interesting. It is not after the “coronation” of Modi at Goa; it was already in the air before. And everybody heard it when Nitish screamed the necessity of using topi at the Ramlila Maidan. Their resolution might not have mentioned the Bad Boy’s name but, they say, it is indication enough. Surprising was when they set a dead line for BJP to declare their Prime Ministerial candidate because the Nation’s mood is increasingly tilted towards a Man, who is causing irritation to the Bihar Chief Minister. And even more surprising was when Nitish mistook 16^th June as 31^st December and calls it Off!

Nitish didn’t have any objection and was part of the alliance when the saffron party was satiated with Ram Bhakti. And the latest released video clearly confirms that Nitish was not suffering from NaMonia in 2003. Am glad Nitish didn’t call them concocted, and those pics there suggest that Modi was no-untouchable post Godhra. Ram Vilas Paswan stepped down. But where was Nitish then? Lalu’s allegation of ‘failing to order a probe’ holds some water and can’t be dismissed.

The country would have appreciated, if Nitish would have said- I want to split because I don’t like the tunic of a person, who is anointed as BJP’s campaign committee chief; but the jerry-built reason given is easily seen through. An agreement with SCS as consideration may be a possibility, Ineludible!

..the extent to which we went wrong

Egypt, Libya and other countries might have witnessed a mass agitation against an INDIVIDUAL. But the civil society movement, against an ISSUE, which India witnessed in the recent past or witnessing today, is unique and sui generis. Some equated it with Jai Prakash’s movement and a few emotionally called it as a ‘second freedom struggle’ for the nation. And there is nothing to dispute if anyone have seen the way the people of country behaved.

On hunger strike and talking to National mediasPhoto courtesy: Jitendra Choudhary

We have participated in the first phase of crusade and are watching, very neutrally, the second phase which Swami Ramdev is leading today. We are neither here to justify his cause nor are part of the smear campaign. When govt is overreacting on his fast and he is getting VVIP treatment; there is nothing to be amazed about. Yes! Govt learned the lesson from history or Anna’s movement in specific. But citizens of this country is definitely surprised when today morning Hazare came up and announced that he will join Baba Ramdev's protest fast in Delhi on June 5.

When the national media is running the show of Civil Society Leadership and division among them, Anna’s step is definitely welcoming. But the justification which he gave to the nation, appears to be absurd. He lashed out at the Centre saying that the government has tried to cheat civil society members on the Lokpal bill and tried to sabotage the Lokpal panel.  

Here, I don’t understand how govt cheated? We asked for notification, govt did; we wanted panel, govt oblidged; we wanted PM and CJI to include under Lokpal, govt discussing it. Kiran Bedi said yesterday that there is no problem govt taking time. After all democracy is a govt by debate and discussion. What’s wrong in it and where govt cheated us?

Yes! There was conflict and controversy over membership from civil society. The issue of father son duo arised… But who raised it? It is Baba Ramdev and the nation and there is nothing wrong. Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion may it be divergent. Secondly, the CD case... Is Anna trying to say that was govt sponsored? I don’t know it might be. But Truth should always see the light no matter when and where.

Am not in full agreement with Vinod Metha but the question remains, when civil society is working with the govt why this Ramdev fast then? Can the Blackmoney be brought with someone fasting? After all we have to give time to the govt. Agreed! they have not done what they should have done and Hon’ble Supreme Court is also annoyed but we have to be realistic. We should allow National debate and help in institution building.

The second most important is that of Lokpal issue. Our dead line was Aug 15, so why this step now? There are 28 more days to June 30^th. Don’t you think civil society doing something which they shouldn’t do now?

Let’s come to the issue of panel now. The objective behind the formation of panel was to debate and discuss on the matters of Lokpal mutually and prepare a draft. Objective was not to impose the society’s draft as the Panel’s draft. Both side have to compromise and ensure which suits the best. When civil society is taking the view of the citizens, govt is equally entitled to. Moreover govt has said that they will get back to them by June 6. Here Arvind Kejriwal threatening to leave the discussion is horrible and is not done. There might be differences of opinion on the so called “issue of divergence” but dialogue must continue. We understand the spirit of civil society (Now or Never) but we have to behave reasonably and not do something for which citizens have to burden their blogs writing all these...

dhadkan of millions..

A 72-year-old man is still in fast and am in deep sleep here! …it didn’t take me, ½ a minute to jump from my bed. ..From yesterday morning, Anna Hazare sat on fast-unto-death at Jantar Mantar and in the evening, I was trying to make my friends, in front of the boys’ hostel, appreciate the implications of Jan Lokpal Bill. I easily convinced people here but politicians were not convinced there (Delhi). 

Anna Hazare on fast-unto-death
Photo Courtesy: The Hindu

The chain hunger strike, of this Anti corruption crusade, will continue till April 11 and a 'Jail Bharo' agitation will be launched on April 12, whereby people and activists will court arrest. At this time, Congress leader Satyavrat Chaturvedi appears with an argument, which was like Malinga’s ball and not that easy to avoid. “You can’t dictate us,” was his argument. It made clear that Congress has not come out from and is still with Montesquieu’ s “Separation of Power.” Yes! There is nothing wrong in it. When Supreme Court made it Basic Structure, politicians should remember it. The underlying thing, which he is trying to put forward, is very  simple- Legislature is entrusted with the power to legislate. The Jan Lokpal bill, which Hazare is pressing for enactment to tackle corruption, is not the legislative creation. They fear the fate of the Act being challenged as Unconstitutional. Moreover the asli fear is the precedent that will be set up..

Completely agreed! When representatives are elected and are given power to legislate, what the construction should be, when citizen try to become part the Drafting Committee? Government can take the advice of people but when civil society is coming up with a bill, is government bound to respect that? I completely understand the compulsions of the government but look, things are different here. The demand is not to pass the Bill, which is prepared by the civil society, as it is. The demand is to form a joint committee, which will prepare a bill. In Parliament, legislature is free to discuss, debate and pass.. None is interested to perform legislatures' duty. And about the question of precedent, what precedent they are talking about? Are the Major Acts of Maharashtra, unconstitutional? Is this government going crazy? Come on! you have good lawyers.. Give some valid reasons for non acceptance or else call media and accept it!   

No constituency or a ward is coming together here on a political call... It is the Nations’ will that is involved and the entire Nation is coming together. No compulsion, no temptation, no lust but see and count the number (of people). Voluntary! Voluntary and Voluntary! A yagna is on and Idam Sareeram rastraya swah, idam na mama (this body is for this Nation and not for self!) is mantra today. It is no less than Gandhiji’s 'National Movement' and we are witness to Ajadi ki dusri ladhai. Mahatma of 50's fought for Self Governance and Modern day Mahatma is standing to fight for Good Governance. The Trust deficit or Mistrust among people is verbalism of this agitation and it will soon become a revolution if ignored. However, we the law students will not mind, if this India v. Corruption case bring to the fore a new proposition of law.

 Arnab Goswami rightly pointed out- “if there is a Will, there will be Bill”. My friends, we are not in a Democracy, which is just elective but India is a Participatory Democracy and I will not be condemnable if I say Legislature and Executive of this country are not above Public Will. Let the Public Will be respected and let my country go by the dhadkan of millions.. 

reshuffle..

Reshuffle, Reshuffle, Reshuffle… Uh-huh, there was a RESHUFFLE. A big ceremony! A big get 2gether! and a big Yo @ the Rashtrapati Bhavan! The swearing-in of the new incumbents took place 2day but the attendance sheet shows no absenteeism and the simply reason is no drop out. Neither those who failed to make a +ve mark nor the damage doer were chucked out. No change in big portfolios like Home, Defence, External Affairs and Finance made me ask a why on caps but Well! the Prime Ministerji is very much within his right to do this drama even though it is hard to appreciate the spur and rationality behind this entire workout.

How can a non performer be a performer in another department? When corruption and price rise is at the vertex, aam aadmi forgot the limit of expectation. Yes! Dr. Shakeel Ahmed is right that govt. had not assured anyth Big. But people can’t be bloody politicians. Right? Media reported that this was an interim measure and the month of May will see the second phase of Cabinet change after the Budget session. But what was the reason of acquiring 15*12 cms of every newspaper is still opaque?

let me tell u sth.

When I signed in to preview my email at swainsatyaranjan@yahoo.com, I found a mail from Mrs. Medha Patkar, an admired social activist, former Commissioner to the World Commission on Dams. The mail was titled as Three Day Bal Mela of Thousands of Children Culminates in the Narmada Valley. On Friday, 16 January, 2009, I had received an invitation mail from NBA to that Bal Mela. But unfortunately I could not able to go. By the way after getting this mail, I suddenly decided to write a few lines about my internship in “Narmada Bachao Andolon” (NBA).
I along with my six colleagues reached “Bhadwani” (MP), where the NBA office located on the dazzling morning of 17th May 2008 with a new vigor and energy for intern. I chose to do my intern with this because I am very much fascinated in movement or institution which concerns to the interest of the tribal and the poor at large. The main objective of my intern is to erect an understanding on people’s movement and develop my own understanding taking both the sides i.e. the people and the State, into consideration and to enlarge the horizon of knowledge from the simple approach to a more complex understanding of violent systems, the perpetuation of these systems by narrow political tactics.
The media bequeath the happenings outside the four walls of our house. But sometimes it conveys the news in such a way that people get the completely negative image unlike me about NBA. I learned from the society where I live in, that the activist and the supporters of the Andolon are anti nationalists and against the development of the country. But after going to NBA, I could able to know that nothing could be more devastating to the nation than permitting the narrow minded politicians to live and rule in this country and oppose NBA. The politicians want to defame and create a false depiction of the Andolon so that the barriers in the process of corruption will be out for the days to come. What not narrow politics do??? The soot in my mind has gone.
The main issue for which NBA stands before the govt. is the "Rehabilitation and Resettlement"- (R&R) of the displaced and affected people. According to the Narmada Water Dispute Tribunal (NWDT), every project-affected family (PAF) should be given land one year prior to the submergence of their land and be rehabilitated completely. But the govt. ignores it like anything.

A EVENING WITH TRIBALS..
In the evening we went to Pichodi, where we met Hari Bhai and others who enlighten us with their experience of many years. The statement of Hari Bhai is mentionable here. “The nature has given us everything. There is nothing to be done more. Govt. should sit ideally because nothing more is to be done but the govt. is destroying and devastating the grants what nature has given us and…”
For the next two days, we had gone to many villages like Baguda, Kundia, Pipri, Piplipat, Chota Borda, Burlai, Sagaon and other where we could able to know a lot of things about the submergence areas. There I have to admit that all this was partly the result of extraordinary crafty tactics on the part of the govt. on the one hand, and obvious official stupidity or naïvete on the other hand.

PRESS CONSULTANCY: A MEMORABLE EXPERIENCE
On 21st to 22nd May, we have attended a press consultancy of the media persons across the country. It was a two days consultancy held in Babangaja. It was in the memorial of the lt. Sanjay Sangbhai, who was not only a journalist but also a ground level activist, writer and litterateur. He was the most effective intervener and strategiser in the present world of corrupt politics, corporatisied economy and increasingly consumerist society and a man of vision, strategy for transformation, culture and ethics, whose commitment were not merely verbalized but practiced. Mr. Amit Prakash and Mr. Chinmaya Mishra were the main attraction of that consultancy. Mr. Kurian, Mr. Himansu, Mr. Robin, Mr. Santanu Mayur, Dr. Saheb, Mr. Shriprakash, Mr. Devesh, Ms. Chitrangada, Ms. Namita, Ms. Bhumika and others were also present in the consultancy. All the invited persons are welcomed by the villagers of Pipri. There held a detail discussion about the Development Paradigm, People’s Movement and the media. The inaugural session was with a struggle song by the people, which adds a great spirit within me. Mr. Chinmay Mishra gave the welcome address. Mr. Amit Prakashji and Ms. Medhaji gave a light about the theme of the development, media and movements. In the 2nd session of that very day, there was a brief discussion about development and displacement, land acquisition, rehabilitation and other laws related to the issue of displacement. On the 3rd session the major discussion was about the privatization of water, water management, Big Dams and other alternatives by the Manthon Team. In that discussion the Hon’ble speaker gave a glance over the privatization of water and the Water ATM or the Pre-paid water metre, which is now used in South Africa. The stage agreed in the same point that it is the most stupid idea of the age. The most important thing which Ms. Medhaji brought to the fore front is that Gujurat is using only 6.5% of the total generation of the water. She criticized the govt. plan of sending water to Rajastan in a strong voice. She compared it with the transferring of capital of Md. Toglak. As the people dies before reaching the capital, similarly the water will die up before reaching there and its not the joke but the reality. In the 4th session there was detail discussion about the Narmada Valley and the SSP project.
People’s movement and the role of media was the topic of discussion on the 6th session, which was held in the very next day i.e. in 22.05.08. In the 7th session the discussion was regarding the media in the present scenario. In the last but not the least there held a very important discussion what can media do? In the another session of the day Ms. Bhumika gave a glance of reality how the editors emphasize on TG (targeted group) and reject the news relating to the social issues. On that day we went to partee, where there was a great breach in medical service.

A DAY IN BHADAL
On the very next day we went to “Bhadal”, a village in the state of Maharastra, which is very far from peoples’ reach. It was a completely a different experience where we had to cross the river to reach over there. During our travelling Medhaji told many things related to dam. There the people and the little school children welcome us in a very fabulous manner. Today I could also recall their slogan “paper wala, kaida wala (they were calling us Kaida wala, as we are the student of law) kudin chha, media wala ….aamra chha and the song of indore wala jaldi aao…cycle chadhi..The environment was a heroic one with the slogan of aamu akha.. eka se by Medhaji. In that programme people shared their experience how the govt. officials drove them in the night, when the river was rising, like anything. The people over there didn’t get any land for their land which was submerged and been made victim for the next generation to come. From this it is very much clear that Victimization is not completely only a North American phenomenon but also in India where the constitution commands for, as Beacon said, Greatest happiness of greatest number. Ms. Medhaji is also running a primary school named Jivaansala, which is building the generation both by educating them and making them aware about their rights (“Jeevanshala Ki Kya Hai Baath…Ladai Padai Sath Sath” (The fact about Jeevanshala is that Struggle and Study goes together), and “Bacha Bacha
Seekhegaa – Andolan Chalayegaa” (Each child will learn and participate in
the Andolan).

A DAY OF LEARNING
On 24th May, I went to RTI office with Ashishji for inspection. There I could able to know a lot of things from Ashishji and others which might not be possible by going through the heavy text materials regarding RTI. After that I went to Mr. Goha, who is the Rehabilitation officer of Thikri Tehsil. I had a brief talk with him about different policies of rehabilitation and others. Some of my friends on that day went to “Piplud” with Medhaji.

A NIGHT IN SAGAON
In Sagaon, we stayed in Hukum Bhai’s house for two days and done the survey of the village. We have also done the survey of those people who are denied of rights of getting land for land and whose major sons are not given the land, showing “encroacher” as the reason. At night after our dinner, Hukum Bhai told a lot of things from both history and mythology about the Narmada River and the Narmada civilization. He told us about the “Sulpaneswar Shiva Temple”, where Markanda Rishi worshipped Lord and in that place Lord Himself had washed His Trident, bloodshed by killing one devil. This temple has already submerged by the dam water. He also told us that the skeleton of the man of primitive was found in the Narmada valley and the Narmada civilization is the 1st civilization. He further added that 1st agriculture was done in “Chikalda”, which is in the Narmada valley. Hukum Bhai is also a supporter of the Andolan.

A MEETING FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF THE TEMPLE
I with one of my friend had attended a meeting, held in Bodhwada, with Ashishji. The SDJM and the SDOP were the chief quest of that meeting. The meeting was to consult the villagers regarding the replacement of the “Budheswar Mahadev temple”, because we are in the so called State of DEMOCRACY, where public opinion is given prime importance. That was the temple of 12th century. It is also believed that this Lord is discovered from the land and there is a cave under that temple. The Lord is also called “Deaopat Ling” by the villagers. The meeting will be memorable one because I have never seen such type of govt. officials before. “…I am not bound to answer each and every question” said the esteemed officer. So, I directly told him that as a govt. official you are accountable and answerable. “….we can’t, you can go to the upper officials.” On the reply, I told him that if it is the system directly to go to the upper levels then why are you?? After the meeting I requested him to answer some question. But the SDOP, Mr. J. Darore, sharply denied, stating that it is his choice. Then I told him that from the date you sit in the public office, your life is no longer private.
This is democracy or demoncracy!

A PATHETIC EXPERIENCE IN MACHALIA
After Sagaon, on 28th May, we went to Machalia, which is in Nanpur. We and the students of Solapur, went there with Kamal Bhai. The Jobat planning is also called Sahid Chandrasekhar Azad Planning. Among one of the affected thirteen villages i.e. Umada, every facilities for rehabilitation has been made but they are not provided those facilities. One of the interesting as well as regretful incident I came across was that a cheque of a Project affected man was issued in another’s name. So, he is going to the bank each and every day from 10-5pm to deliver the cheque. It was told that 9000 hectar of land will be irrigated but it has not yet done even after the completion of the project. In this village we stayed for a day. But this was a pathetic experience. There were no facilities available. We slept outside like in Sagaon. But… a hot day with… (“…” not to remember bad experience. )

TWO DAYS IN A BEAUTIFUL VILLAGE
Bhawaria is a very beautiful village. That will submerge in 138m height of the dam. The survey is not conducted in that village. A large no. of people have received only 1st installment and could not able to purchase the land. So, they could not able to get the 2nd installment. There was the large nos. of case related to forgery registration and ex partee allotment.

A VISIT TO NISHARPUR
My self with one of my friend went to Nisharpur to do a survey regarding the Special Rehabilitation Package. There we stayed in one of the activists of NBA. The daughter in law of that activist uncle was very hospitable. For the first time in that long month, I got good food just like prepared by my mother. But the people in that village were very uncooperative. We could not able to complete the survey. One of them tried a lot to convenience the people. But all his labour was in vain. We have to return without completing the survey.

KEVADIYA: AN EXCELLENT EXPERIENCE
I and my friends with Wilson, a student of Tamil Nadu, went to Baroda, on 11th June from Barwani to attend the public meeting & press conference which was to be held in Kevadiya near to the dam site. Kevadiya is a village about 100 km. from Baroda and the Sardar Sarovar Dam is just 8km from the village. There the govt. has taken 1700 acres of lands of the villagers for construction of dam but 1400acres are not of any use. So, it is constructing its own buildings, quest houses, restaurants etc. But the people over there were in relay hunger strike for the last nine months in protest of it. The govt. is not listening anything. Medhaji joined with them and make the official to accept the grievance of the people and the official promised to return the land of the villagers within a month. The people went for a rally after that and I with some of my friends return to Baroda with Medhaji. The returning trip was the interesting one. The DSP with police came and stopped us to go to Baroda because the collector and the SP have told that there is danger to Medhaji’s life. After the long time the police allowed us to go further and accompanied us up to the station. They also came with us after leaving Medhaji in the station. They compel us to give all our details, took our photos and accompanied us to the border of Gujurat. This was our last visit to the villages, which will be memorable for the days to come…

ENDING UP WITH…
Nothing left to say more than saying that what is going on over there in the name of development is not right… if devastating the brilliantly settled village, snatching the smiles from those innocent faces, obliterating the natural world, spreading clamor amongst the people, sitting gently after pushing those lives into the whirlpool of water and violating the constitutional & fundamental rights is development. Then I will surely say NBA is against development. The soot which is in my mind about NBA disappears after coming here. May the people understand the movement in the right sense and give strength, support to lead the nation to the heights?